Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller is pushing back against one of the central bank’s favorite tools: telling markets exactly what it plans to do next.

Waller cautioned that overly strong or rigid forward guidance can actually become a liability for policymakers, particularly when the economic landscape is clouded by conflicting signals and multiple plausible outcomes.

The case against policy autopilot

Forward guidance is essentially the Fed’s practice of telegraphing future rate decisions to reduce market surprises. It became a cornerstone tool during the post-2008 era when interest rates were pinned near zero and the central bank needed other ways to influence financial conditions.

Inflationary pressures tied to ongoing geopolitical tensions in the Middle East have muddied the outlook considerably. When you can’t confidently predict whether inflation will cool, accelerate, or do something entirely unexpected, promising a specific policy path starts to look less like transparency and more like a trap.