(Image credit: Dan Bracaglia/Tom's Guide)
Which Fitbit Air band is best? I tried all three, and there’s a clear winner.The screen-free and subscription-optional Fitbit Air is Google's answer to the Whoop 5.0 fitness tracker, and one of the best fitness trackers in 2026. Starting at $99, users can select from three strap types — though, more are in the works — including two woven options and one silicone.I've been wearing the Fitbit Air for over a week and tested all three options, both while working out and hanging out. Here's how I rank them.Third place: Fitbit Active BandPrice: $34.99 or $99 with Fitbit AirStyles: Obsidian, Lavender, Berry, FogSizes: Small (130-175mm), Large (165-210mm)Material: Silicone
(Image credit: Dan Bracaglia/Tom's Guide)In third place, we have the silicone Fitbit Active Band, available in your choice of four colors, including Berry, shown here. This option is sold either kitted with the Fitbit Air for $99 or on its own for $34.99 via Google directly.As far as rubbery/silicone straps go, this one is fairly soft on the skin; however, several factors detract from its appeal.For starters, the Active Band is both thicker and less flexible than the woven strap options. It also secures to your wrist with a pin-and-buckle style system, so you can't make micro-adjustments for maximum comfort. That said, two sizes are available.Finally, I'm not a fan of how silicone feels on my skin, in general, when I'm super sweaty. So, the Fitbit Active Band was never going to be my top choice.Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips.Second place: Fitbit Performance LoopPrice: $34.99 or $99 with Fitbit AirStyles: Obsidian, Lavender, Berry, FogSize: One size (130-210mm)Material: Woven polyester and elastane fabric, stainless steel buckle
