Harvard Business Review LogoAntonio SortinoCompanies that systematically track referral behavior uncover a powerful, underutilized growth engine. An analysis of more than 10 million consumers reveals that while about 20% of new customersJust eight years after its launch, ButcherBox, a subscription-based retailer of premium meat and seafood, rocketed past sales of $600 million. Initially the firm grew by marketing through paid influencers, but over time it increased its dependence on buying new customer leads through digital advertising. Then customer acquisition costs began spiraling as paid influencers and social media and search websites raised their prices. Meanwhile, the quality of the customers produced by the paid channels declined: They made smaller purchases, filled their baskets with a less attractive product mix, and defected at higher rates.