When it comes time to sell your car, there’s one potentially painful question that you have to ask yourself: Should I go with a practical replacement, or spring for something fun?

For most of us, the logical answer is usually the practical car. Even though there are plenty of interesting and reliable cars on the market, the alternative—something big and loud or speedy and sporty—can be tempting. After all, a quiet, dependable sedan doesn’t turn as many heads as some of the flashier, faster, and cooler options that are on the market today.

As car owners debate this decision, they often find themselves searching for a middle ground: A car that is cool, dependable, and practical without being too boring.

Now, one woman’s car-buying debate has her turning to the internet for help. What should she choose?

Should She Trade In Her Jeep?