This was a long time coming. Twenty-six years, to be exact. Twenty-six years since the baseball team in Cleveland made this many trips to the bank to withdraw prospects at the trade deadline.Chris Antonetti was an assistant in the baseball operations department and Mike Chernoff was a freshman shortstop at Princeton when then-general manager John Hart traded for Bob Wickman, Jason Bere and Steve Woodard of the Milwaukee Brewers at the deadline in 2000. Hart also acquired David Segui and Wil Cordero in separate deals that reshaped the roster in about 24 hours.No single day of trading for the franchise has been that volatile since. Antonetti and Chernoff didn’t have to relinquish a prospect as highly regarded as Richie Sexson to do it, either. Now, whether any of the eight minor leaguers the Guardians surrendered this week go on to productive careers remains to be seen, but the point remains that this franchise saw an opportunity in a wide-open American League and seized it.Outside of Tarik Skubal and the Los Angeles Dodgers, who acquired more for less this week than the Guardians?Who won and lost the MLB trade deadline?Andy McCullough and Johnny SweetWhile the rest of the league buzzes over Adley Rutschman heading to the Boston Red Sox or the Tampa Bay Rays buying low on Freddy Peralta or the Chicago Cubs acquiring Kevin Gausman, the Guardians quietly surrendered just one top 30 prospect and received two drastic upgrades to the lineup, plus an All-Star pitcher and a reliever.Outfielder Jo Adell slugged 30 home runs off righties last year and had an OPS over .900 against lefties. He has scuffled a bit this year and certainly has his flaws, but he still enters the clubhouse as Cleveland’s new leader in home runs. Nathaniel Lowe mashes right-handers and is an upgrade over Kyle Manzardo at first base.Foster Griffin doesn’t overpower anyone, but he has excellent command and throws a variety of pitches. He should thrive in Cleveland’s pitching-rich environment.There is no bogeyman in the American League this summer. The Rays are excellent and Peralta will help, but they aren’t infallible. The New York Yankees failed to obtain a catcher and didn’t address their bullpen at the deadline. The Chicago White Sox’s biggest move was taking on a worn-down veteran in Luis Castillo. Teams like the Seattle Mariners and Houston Astros could threaten in October — if they get to the postseason.With a payroll among the lowest in the game, a looming work stoppage threatening next season, a desolate field of contenders, excellent pitching and enough internal development to envision a path to the ALCS with just a little help, Antonetti and Chernoff reached into the vault and delivered at the perfect time.There’s also the José Ramírez component. This organization owes it to Ramírez to go for it before it’s too late. Ramírez, who turns 34 next month, hasn’t enjoyed a typical season by his standards. I’m going to choose to believe it was a slow start coupled with the hamate fracture and not the beginning of his decline … at least for now.A strong argument can be made that Ramírez has given this organization at least $150 million and perhaps even $200 million in mail-in rebates over the years by signing two club-friendly extensions. Otherwise, he would’ve been traded long ago. At some point, the Guardians owe it to him to exhaust the resources necessary to give him a legitimate chance at a championship. It’s been 78 years since the franchise’s last title, and the meter is still running.Nobody has any idea what baseball will look like under a new collective-bargaining agreement. Cleveland will have Adell under contract next season, provided there is a 2027 season. Lowe is likely just a rental, with prospect Ralphy Velazquez coming fast, and although Griffin is also a free agent after the season, he seems like an ideal extension candidate to remain beyond this season.A decent comp for a Griffin extension might be the three-year, $51 million deal Michael Wacha signed with the Kansas City Royals in 2024. Griffin is a couple of years younger, but he hasn’t had the sustained success Wacha had at the time of his deal. Given the Guardians’ pitifully low payroll, that type of framework should easily slide into their budget whenever baseball returns after this season. I’ve wondered for a few months if players like Griffin will have any urgency to get a new deal in place before the end of the season, given the unknown of what baseball could look like under a new CBA.Those are decisions for another day. For now, underrate this team at your own peril. The Guardians’ biggest obstacle in October has always been an inability to hit home runs in the postseason. Adell helps address that. So, too, does Lowe. If the wheels stay attached for Steven Kwan, the Guardians can consistently produce a lineup with legitimate threats in at least seven slots in the order.That may not sound imposing, but this is an organization that has long been constructed on run prevention, and it will be again this fall. They just needed a little help. In a thin American League where someone has to win it, the Guardians just pulled a seat up to the table.
Guardians announce they’re contenders with busiest trade deadline in more than 25 years
Jo Adell and Nathaniel Lowe will provide some punch for a solid team that saw an opportunity in a wide-open American League and seized it.













