The generous acreage of the property and its uses may also be a drawback for some buyers.

While the house sits on an 8-acre parcel, "3.2 acres is reserved for agricultural use exclusively," Jonathan Yarton, a New York-based agent from "Selling the Hamptons" on HBO Max, told Realtor.com in March.

He also warned that the expansive acreage isn't exactly a perk from everyone's point of view.

However, Diana Rafailova Schwartz, a licensed real estate broker and the founder of Aleph Realty, who represents high-end residential and commercial properties across New York City, the Hamptons, Miami, and Palm Beach, was more optimistic about the potential in the home.

Rafailova Schwartz believed that the right buyer is someone who will enjoy the estate's family assets, flexibility, and eventually, profit potential.