July 10, 2026
The publisher Springer Nature reversed its retraction of two papers by renowned physicist and Nobel laureate Max Planck after more than a decade, based on the findings of two historians who investigated the matter, Science reported.
The papers—published in the 1940s in a German journal, Naturwissenschaften, now owned by Springer Nature—were retracted in 2011 due to “human error,” according to the publisher. Suzanne Scarlata, the current editor in chief of the journal, since renamed The Science of Nature, told Science she suspected the publisher’s internal policing software was at fault for the mistaken retractions, which Springer Nature denies.
“It appears that the decision to retract the papers was a human error and we can confirm that no software or ‘bot’ would have been involved in the process,” a Springer Nature spokesperson told Science.
Brown Professor Suspects Most of His Class Used AI to Cheat
