The Windup Newsletter ⚾ | This is The Athletic’s MLB newsletter. Sign up here to receive The Windup directly in your inbox.Last night, we got history from two players you might not expect. Plus: A draft primer from Melissa Lockard, some All-Star replacements and we construct an all-time lineup of … well, you’re gonna want to stick around for this one.I’m Levi Weaver — welcome to The Windup!HistoryLast night, we got two historic performances. Let’s get to ’em.Ryan O’Hearn’s RBI-festHere’s how rare a 10-RBI night is: There have been 21 four-homer games and 15 unassisted triple plays in MLB history. Last night, Pirates first baseman Ryan O’Hearn pulled off a feat that goes somewhere in between those two, becoming the 17th player in league history to drive in 10 RBIs in one game, hitting three home runs, including a first-inning grand slam. It led to a Pirates (47-45) rout of the Braves (52-38), 12-4.In case you’re wondering, the big-league single-game RBI record is 12, set by Jim Bottomley in 1924, then tied by Mark Whiten in 1993 (coincidentally, both with the St. Louis Cardinals).See the full list of the other 10-RBIers here, and the video of all O’Hearn’s home runs on MLB.com.Tyler Tolbert’s even dozen If you think O’Hearn’s feat was rare, how about this? According to Sarah Langs at MLB, only two hitters in MLB history — Johnny Kling of the 1902 Chicago (they weren’t even known as the Cubs until two years later) and Walt Dropo of the 1952 Detroit Tigers — had recorded hits in 12 consecutive plate appearances*.They now have some speedy company: Royals outfielder Tyler Tolbert, who tied the major-league record by collecting 12 consecutive hits over three days.The streak started with a 2-for-2 appearance on Saturday against the Phillies, but really got going in Monday’s 15-1 win over the Phillies, when Tolbert went 5-for-5.Then last night, things got weird. Tolbert’s night started with him standing between home and first base, helplessly holding the ball at the end of a three-error Little League home run. However, in the second inning, Tolbert homered. After a single to right, he then beat out three consecutive infield singles before a ninth-inning flyout ended the streak.In addition to tying the record, Tolbert became the first player since Roberto Clemente in 1970 to have back-to-back five-hit games.But my favorite part of this story is this: Before this streak began, Tolbert had more big-league stolen bases (28) than hits (21). (He’s now at 33 hits and 31 steals.)*Two others have gotten hits in 12 consecutive at-bats: José Miranda (2024, Twins) and Pinky Higgins (1938, Red Sox).