A modern take on a classic favorite, this blendable stick comes in tons of colors and can be used in oh, so many ways...

Don’t be fooled by its straightforward packaging; this eyeliner pencil is versatile. You can find it in dozens of colors, from neutrals to neons, and apply it as a traditional eyeliner, a cream liner or even an eyeshadow. The huge color selection is ideal for creative looks and everyday glam alike, offering hues for all sorts of tones and tastes.

“I use the smoke gray because the black is too dark for my 65+ years,” shopper Sharon wrote. “Bourbon is a stunning deep brown with subtle warm undertones,” another said. “Softer and more versatile than black but still bold enough to define your eyes.” Many love the shade Rockstar, a dark matte purple, for adding “depth without looking harsh.”

Shoppers celebrate how creamy the formula is, giving superior pigmentation and staying power without feeling chalky or dry.

The formula is designed to go on smoothly, giving you time to blend and adjust as needed. But, “once it sets, it stays put,” Cris writes, not fading or transferring through the day. “It truly glides on...no tugging, no skipping, no fighting with a dry pencil that gives up halfway through your lash line,” they added. “The texture feels more like a beautiful gel in pencil form, and the color payoff is rich and deep from the first swipe...If you’re tired of eyeliners that dry out, drag, or crumble, this one is such a relief to use.”