At a security forum in Singapore, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth sought to convince US allies that staying quiet on Taiwan is the best way to project American strength. While time will tell if that’s the case, for the moment it’s a win for Chinese President Xi Jinping.

Hegseth over the weekend became the first Pentagon chief in more than a decade to avoid mentioning Taiwan during a speech that lasted about 30 minutes at the annual Shangri-La Dialogue. He declared “the era of performative outrage is over” while outlining a “strong, quiet and clear” policy toward the region, and hailing ties with Beijing as “better than they’ve been in many years.”

The softer language, a sharp contrast from Hegseth’s address a year ago, came just weeks after Xi cautioned Donald Trump in Beijing that mishandling the Taiwan situation could lead to “clashes” between the superpowers. While Hegseth also noted “rightful alarm” at China’s military buildup and showered nearly every Asian country with praise for boosting defense spending, the overall tone showed an eagerness to sidestep tensions with Beijing.

“On China, something had clearly changed: this was perhaps the least confronting speech from a US administration in the 23-year history of the Shangri-la Dialogue,” said Rory Medcalf, head of the National Security College at the Australian National University. “The great uncertainty is whether this all reflects strength or vulnerability in the US negotiating position.”