As Trump threatens funding and public trust plummets, US schools are in the fight of a lifetime. This is how they can survive – with their souls intact
It is no secret that American universities are in the fight of a lifetime. With billions of dollars in federal support on the line, their ability to fund their research activities is clearly at stake. But for the biggest targets, such as Harvard, their pockets are unfathomably deep. While cuts may be painful, no financial threat is likely to be existential. What is harder to know is whether universities can come out of their current predicament with their souls intact.
The groundwork for this situation has been in the making for more than a decade. While the destruction is a bipartisan phenomenon, early warning signs appeared in “cancel culture”, the left’s version of campus censoriousness. More recently, the right’s version has been even more brazen, as seen in boorish attempts by the Trump administration and some state governors to control what is taught in university classrooms.
The response from universities is similarly dispiriting. Universities have not articulated what they are fighting for, and are not even particularly clear how much they are willing to fight against. Feckless administrators, along with faculty who have lost their intellectual curiosity, have left the university a punching bag for competing factions: angry students, entitled donors and opportunistic politicians. Large settlement payments by Ivy League colleges may be an expedient way to restore federal funding, but hardly demonstrate much backbone or conviction about academic integrity. Worse, monitoring agreements, such as the one Columbia has agreed to, raise troubling questions about the extent to which schools are willing to compromise academic freedom in exchange for turning the money spouts back on.
