Not all skin care is created equal, but that doesn’t mean it has to cost a ton of money, either. Just take a look at E.l.f.’s Thirst Burst Pore-fecting toner, which is on sale for just $5 today. Called a “super find” by one 70-year-old reviewer who swears it’s helping them maintain “hardly a wrinkle” on their face, this 2% BHA formula is gentle enough to use daily, yet powerful enough to reduce the visibility of pores, according to reviewers. For $5? That’s a steal if we’ve ever seen one.

This stuff has all the hallmarks of a drugstore superstar. As one reviewer sums it up, “It’s cheap, and it doesn’t irritate my skin.”

As far as value is concerned, so many reviewers say this small bottle of toner is unbeatable, especially considering how well it works for its price. Folks say it really helps even out skin tone and suppress breakouts. One even says it makes their “face feels softer and way more clean after use.”

“Does anyone else remember when e.l.f. was like the super cheap makeup brand that you only bought when you needed to use something once or twice and didn’t want to spend a fortune?” asks one reviewer who calls this their favorite face product. “This is not that e.l.f. anymore. Their stuff has come a LONG way, and I’m so so impressed by the quality of their products.”