The tradeFlorida Panthers get: Brady TkachukOttawa Senators get: No. 9 and No. 25 in the 2026 NHL Draft, a first-round pick in 2029 (top-10 protected) and a second-round pick in 2027Shayna Goldman: For weeks, rumors have been swirling around Team USA players. Looks like Brady Tkachuk’s plans are the first to make it out of the group chat.To contenders like the Panthers, draft picks are just trade assets; most players selected with those picks won’t be difference-makers while this team is in its playoff window. Considering what management has already invested in this window and the fact that the team is coming off a lost year, it makes sense that Florida would go even further in with a trade of this magnitude.In Tkachuk, the Panthers add a winger who drives scoring chances and is coming off a season in which he scored at the highest pace of his career. It may seem like a surplus of riches, but building a deeper team matters a lot here. The Atlantic Division is only getting more competitive (even if the Senators are taking a step back with this deal), and Florida’s core isn’t getting any younger. As great of a player as Brad Marchand is still (and he is!), the reality is that he is 38 years old. Carter Verhaeghe has taken a step back over the past couple of seasons, too. This Tkachuk deal helps punch up the top-nine with another star-caliber add.It just comes at a really high price. Even if Tkachuk extends in two years and even if it’s at a discount, it’s a high price for someone who never proved he could be a franchise forward in Ottawa. The good news is, he doesn’t have to be that in Florida. He slides into a No. 3 or No. 4 role behind his brother and Aleksander Barkov, and will be a key contributor instead of The Guy. His footspeed is one other potential pitfall, as well as the fact that the team is low on assets, with more work to do, like figuring out the goaltending situation.This one obviously stings for the Senators, who climbed their way back into the playoff circle, only to lose one of their best players. There are two ways to look at the return. The No. 9 pick is extremely valuable and the best way for Ottawa to find its next franchise player. There’s delayed gratification in waiting for another first in 2029, but it should be worth it. The Panthers could be on the downswing by then, so that could be a higher pick than it would be in the next couple of years.This could be the Senators’ best chance to build a stronger window of contention, since this one was always going to be flawed by the fact that their No. 1 forward really wasn’t high-caliber enough to be a franchise cornerstone. The big looming question of whether their captain wanted to be a part of that next wave in Ottawa didn’t help, either.The flip side, though, is that a pick-filled return is filled with uncertainty. Drafting and developing players is the best way to bring in stars, but it’s a long process with a lot of unknowns. So adding some difference-making NHL-caliber talent would have gone a long way to softening the blow of this trade. The Senators have more trade assets to work with now, but it’s going to take a lot of creativity to keep everything afloat after rebuilding for so long to even get to this point.Panthers grade: B+
NHL grades: Tkachuk trade sets Senators back, adds to Panthers’ already-strong arsenal
The Senators lose one of their best two forwards, while the Panthers pay four picks to become even harder to play against.













