Show Caption
Russell Wilson will go down as the greatest quarterback in the history of the Seattle Seahawks (assuming Sam Darnold’s mid-career revival plateaus at some point).Beyond that?Wilson, aka “DangeRuss,” aka “Mr. Unlimited,” aka the man behind “Let Russ Cook,” could have one of the more complicated legacies in recent NFL history as his career comes to a close. It evidently ended with the official announcement on June 3 that he’ll be dropping dimes as a CBS analyst for the upcoming season rather than dropping them on a field – along with slick social media posts that simply said, “Thank You, Football. Love, #3,” alongside a three-minute video … though, notably, Wilson never uttered the word "retiring" on Wednesday.Whether he's finished playing or not, the question has been asked before − but you can bet the debate will be renewed with vigor: Is Wilson a Hall of Famer?For some, he’ll be a slam dunk.“I think he is,” longtime ESPN analyst and former NFL safety Louis Riddick told USA TODAY Sports.“His big-play ability, his toughness, his leadership, winning a Super Bowl, coming a play away from winning another one – he wins two Super Bowls, we wouldn’t even be talking about this.“Clearly there’s going to be people who argue against him, I believe. … It’s gonna be a very polarizing conversation, I’m sure.”To say the least.Riddick absolutely hit on some of Wilson’s best HOF arguments, which also include being one of the most efficient passers ever while generating as many highlights as anyone who's ever played his position. He entered the league quietly as a third-round pick in 2012 yet won Seattle’s QB1 job by the end of his first training camp and owned it for the next decade.Yet Wilson was a spoke on the Seahawks’ “Legion of Boom”-era teams, not the hub – even on offense, which ran through bruising tailback Marshawn “Beast Mode” Lynch. And the play Wilson is best known for – his final Super Sunday snap, at the conclusion of his third season – was his infamous goal-line interception against the New England Patriots in the final seconds of Super Bowl 49, a miscue that cost Seattle back-to-back crowns and maybe even derailed what seemed like a nascent dynasty. Key members of that Seahawks team, broadcaster Cris Collinsworth, who was in the booth, and 12s around the world still can’t believe Wilson didn’t hand off to Lynch – former Seattle defensive lineman Brandon Mebane even revealing last year that Wilson opted to pass.In later years, the Seahawks offense began to revolve around Wilson, yet the team’s playoff success deteriorated – Seattle never returning to the NFC championship game during his tenure.Still, had Wilson hung up his cleats after the 2021 season, he probably walks a pretty clear path to Canton. Instead, he was traded to the Denver Broncos for a package that included multiple first- and second-round picks, yet flamed out almost immediately in the Rocky Mountains. His proclivity to extend plays in hopes of big gainers or points – “Let Russ Cook,” which quite frequently bailed the Seahawks out of jams – became a drawback in Denver, where his offensive limitations and tendency to freelance (for better or worse) were laid bare. Coach Sean Payton, who inherited Wilson in 2023, was critical, telling him, "Will you (expletive) stop kissing all the babies?” per ESPN. "You're not running for public office."Personal as that was and frustrated by Wilson’s inability to execute the offense to his standard, Payton eventually benched him and accepted a record $85 million dead salary cap charge to get rid of him a few months later. Wilson had an encouraging start with the Pittsburgh Steelers in 2024, winning his first four starts. But the bottom ultimately fell out, the team ending the season on a five-game skid that included a blowout loss at Baltimore in the playoffs. Wilson started three games for the New York Giants in 2025 before losing his job to rookie Jaxson Dart.“If ever there was somebody who played himself out of a Hall of Fame, it’s Russell Wilson. And I say that because look at what’s happened. Ever since he left Seattle – when he was in Seattle, he was the man,” Hall of Fame tight end Tony Gonzalez, now an analyst for Prime Video, said last September.“I just don’t think he’s done himself any favors since he left Seattle.”Gonzalez’s Amazon colleague, former Seahawks All-Pro cornerback Richard Sherman, a teammate of Wilson’s during their Super Bowl years, offered more damning criticism.“I think you’ve got to judge his career off when the ‘Legion of Boom’ was there – he had a legendary defense, an all-time defense and how much success he had – and then without that legendary defense,” said Sherman, among the players still irked by the Super Bowl INT.“He was a winning football player in Seattle,” Sherman continued. “And now you get to go on your own, and you get to prove, ‘Hey, I’m this great quarterback, I’m this guy that’s gonna be dominant.’ And it just hasn’t worked out that way.”Sherman, memorably caught wincing by sideline cameras in Super Bowl 49’s aftermath, couldn’t even bear to say Wilson’s name when recalling the episode.“It’s tough, it’s tough,” said Sherman. “You feel like you’ve got the game won. We sacrificed – guys were beat up, guys were injured coming into that game. You just have to turn around and hand it off to Marshawn Lynch. We didn’t. Quarterback threw an interception. Game.”Truly a football Rorschach test, Wilson was obviously instrumental in getting Seattle that far … despite throwing four interceptions in the 2014 NFC championship game … before lofting the game-winning touchdown pass in overtime. He’s the same guy who visited Seattle Children's Hospital on a weekly basis … yet was critiqued for publicizing them. Wilson was unfailingly upbeat in interviews and after losses, always looking for silver linings and taking accountability in the midst of adversity … yet was also crushed for his cheesy “Mr. Unlimited” social media post and the “Broncos Country, let's ride" coda to his news conferences in Denver, which became increasingly uncomfortable as the team cratered to 5-12 in 2022. And there was also the time he and wife Ciara announced a contract extension … from their boudoir.Some of that has nothing to do with football, yet leaves an indelible impression of the man, who was also beloved by quite a few teammates, especially as Wilson's career wore on. Some of it has everything to do with football – and let’s be sure to note Wilson’s 121 regular-season victories as a starter, which currently rank 12th all time, right behind Hall of Famer Fran Tarkenton, whose jailbreak style very much resembled Wilson’s. And what about the nearly 400 regular-season touchdowns Wilson accounted for?And listen to the testimony of former Broncos teammate Dalton Risner, a member of that ill-fated 2022 team in Denver."I respect him so much. I respect the way he integrates within our locker room, and I feel like all year, he hasn't been able to catch a break. People just making up rumors about him, whether that be he's not a good teammate or he's lost the locker room, apparently, or whatever it is," Risner told Denver's ABC affiliate that season."We may not be having a good season, we may be 3-8, but I respect the heck out of Russell Wilson and the way he's leading this football team amongst everything he's had to deal with this year."Maybe Wilson was never the guy who was going to get the ball out quickly or methodically march a team down the field or galvanize a locker room the way Drew Brees so often did for Payton in New Orleans. But Wilson was also the obverse of Brees, who was never going to salvage a busted play with a 10-second scramble behind the line of scrimmage before launching a decisive moonball touchdown that covered 60 yards.And so the Wilson-Rorschach test will apparently be gauged in 2031 by Hall of Fame voters, the same group that denied Bill Belichick admission into Canton. Yet it’s also a good bet they’ll wave Lynch and Sherman into immortality before Wilson’s case is officially discussed.Legion of Boom or (bronze) bust for Russ? Expect an enthralling debate to continue.Let’s ride.All NFL news on and off the field. Sign up for USA TODAY's 4th and Monday newsletter.
