A laid-off IIT graduate has ignited a fierce online debate after claiming that medicine is the only truly safe, secure and AI-proof profession left in India.Posting on Reddit's IndiaCareers forum, the engineer revealed that he lost his job at a major American tech company and has been struggling to find work despite graduating from a top-tier institute and receiving referrals."As you guys know the current job market, Big Tech companies are laying off employees because of rapid AI investment and replacement. I got laid off too and have been applying for jobs for two months with no response," he wrote.The techie argued that doctors enjoy something increasingly rare in the corporate world — job security."I always feel MBBS is the safest, most stable field. No layoff tension and 100% job security. A doctor cannot be unemployed," he wrote, adding that experienced doctors can earn ?5-6 lakh per month or more.He even pointed to luxury cars parked outside Mumbai hospitals as proof of the profession's earning potential."I have seen BMW X7s, Mercedes GLS SUVs, Audi RS5s and even a Porsche 911 in hospital parking lots," he claimed.The IIT graduate also challenged the popular notion that engineering is a better career choice than medicine, arguing that many BTech graduates struggle to find well-paying jobs while doctors continue to enjoy strong demand.But the post quickly drew a reality check from medical professionals.One doctor from West Bengal responded with a lengthy post, calling medicine anything but an easy route to wealth."As a resident physician, I always find it amusing when people from engineering or IT assume medicine is some magical AI-proof, recession-proof golden ticket where everyone eventually drives a BMW or Porsche," the doctor wrote.The physician highlighted the grueling journey doctors face — 5.5 years of MBBS, years of postgraduate training, multiple entrance exams, exhausting work schedules and uncertain job prospects."People see the consultant with the BMW X7. They don't see the 15-20 years it took to reach there," the doctor said.According to the physician, many residents work 80 to 100 hours a week while earning salaries that often fail to reflect the immense workload.The doctor also challenged the belief that medical professionals enjoy guaranteed government jobs."Permanent government posts are limited. Many young specialists spend years doing contractual jobs, ad-hoc appointments and temporary positions," the physician wrote.Another specialist echoed the sentiment, saying medicine may be more resistant to AI disruption but is far from the "golden goose" many outsiders imagine."While medicine is AI-proof, it isn't the golden goose people think it is. Many doctors wait more than a decade to earn what tech professionals can make within a few years of graduation," the specialist wrote.The viral exchange highlights growing anxiety in India's tech sector as artificial intelligence reshapes the employment landscape. While some see medicine as a refuge from automation and layoffs, doctors insist the profession comes with its own set of sacrifices, pressures and uncertainties.One thing is certain: the debate over which careers can survive the AI revolution is only getting louder.
'Doctors have BMWs, Audis': IIT engineer, who got laid off by a American big tech company, says MBBS is the only AI-proof career left in India; doctors fire back
An IIT graduate's claim that medicine is India's safest career is sparking debate. He argues AI and tech layoffs make doctor jobs more secure. While some agree healthcare is insulated, others highlight the demanding medical education and early career struggles. This reflects growing anxiety among tech professionals as AI reshapes industries.












