Skip to Content Subscribe Our Offers My Account Manage My Subscriptions FAQ Newsletters Canada Canadian True Crime Canadian Politics Health World Israel & Middle East Financial Post NP Comment Longreads Puzzmo Diversions Comics NP News Quiz New York Times Crossword Horoscopes Life Eating & Drinking Style Sponsored Play for Ontario Travel Travel Canada Travel USA Travel International Cruises Travel Essentials Culture Books Celebrity Movies Music Theatre Television Business Essentials Advice Lives Told Tails Told Shopping Buy Canadian Home Living Outdoor Living Tech Style & Beauty Kitchen & Dining Personal Care Entertainment & Hobbies Gift Guide Travel Guide Deals Savings National Post Store More Sports Hockey Baseball Basketball Football Soccer Golf Tennis Driving Vehicle Research Reviews News Gear Guide Obituaries Place an Obituary Place an In Memoriam Classifieds Place an Ad Celebrations Working Business Ads Archives Healthing Epaper Manage Print Subscription Profile Settings My Subscriptions Saved Articles My Offers Newsletters Customer Service FAQ Newsletters Canada World Financial Post NP Comment Longreads Puzzmo Diversions Life Shopping Epaper Manage Print Subscription HomeNP CommentScott Stinson: Ontario Liberal leadership race is off to a messy startThe party has rejected an appeal from federal MP Nate Erskine-Smith in a disputed nomination race You can save this article by registering for free here. Or sign-in if you have an account.After their involvement in a contentious nomination race, Nate Erskine-Smith and Navdeep Bains could bring some more drama to the Ontario Liberal leadership race. Photo by Peter J. Thompson/National Post; Blair Gable/Postmedia; FilesNavdeep Bains declared his candidacy to lead the Ontario Liberals on Monday with a video that only someone confident of winning would produce.Enjoy the latest local, national and international news.Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events.Unlimited online access to National Post.National Post ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on.Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword.Support local journalism.Enjoy the latest local, national and international news.Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events.Unlimited online access to National Post.National Post ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on.Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword.Support local journalism.Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience.Access articles from across Canada with one account.Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments.Enjoy additional articles per month.Get email updates from your favourite authors.Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience.Access articles from across Canada with one accountShare your thoughts and join the conversation in the commentsEnjoy additional articles per monthGet email updates from your favourite authorsSign In or Create an AccountorThe former minister in Justin Trudeau’s federal cabinet doesn’t introduce himself or even say anything, just sits down and rolls up his sleeves before “Let’s get to work” is flashed on the screen.His name, helpfully, is flashed at the end of the brief clip, for the benefit of the viewers — presumably a great many of them — who did not immediately recognize the man who left an executive job at Rogers to return to political life.And why wouldn’t he be confident? Bains is said to have the backing of some party heavyweights, and his registered opponents so far are rookie Toronto MPP Lee Fairclough and Dylan Marando, a backroom staffer. Ajax MPP Rob Cerjanec, also first elected just last year, is expected to join them.The one wild card? That would be Bains’ former colleague in the Trudeau government, current Beaches-East York MP Nate Erskine-Smith. He announced plans to run again for the provincial leadership, having lost to Bonnie Crombie in the 2023 contest, but has not been what you would call welcomed to the party. The Ontario Liberals have treated Erskine-Smith not unlike a bridge troll might regard a weary traveller who lacks the proper coin for passage.Erskine-Smith lost a Liberal nomination race for an upcoming byelection in Scarborough by just 19 votes to businessman Ahsanul Hafiz. The MP, who represents the neighbouring riding federally, has said that he faced opposition from party insiders during the local campaign, and he appealed the results of the May 9 vote, citing a host of alleged irregularities, including mismatched vote totals and questionable approval of the eligibility of certain voters. (Hafiz is from Bangladesh and thanked the riding’s large Bengali community for supporting him after winning the race; non-citizens were eligible to take part in the vote provided they lived in the riding.)This newsletter from NP Comment tackles the topics you care about. (Subscriber-exclusive edition on Fridays)By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc.We encountered an issue signing you up. Please try againThat appeal was dismissed by an arbitration committee on Sunday night after a hearing last week. But interim Liberal leader John Fraser had declared himself satisfied that there had been a “fair, open and transparent” nomination race on the night of the May 9 vote even after Erskine-Smith had raised concerns about elements of it, and Fraser brought Hafiz to Queen’s Park to meet reporters before the appeal period had ended.He told reporters that Erskine-Smith had to “prove it” if he suspected unfairness, and suggested the losing candidate was just saying “things in the heat of the moment.”The Ontario Liberals did not sound terribly interested in a thorough investigation of Erskine-Smith’s claims, in other words.The appeal hearing was not public, but the arbitration committee’s 17-page report was released, and it is a step-by-step repudiation of Erskine-Smith’s claims. Not that his supporters are likely to see it that way.On, for example, Erskine-Smith’s allegation that there were 34 more votes than there were names crossed off on the voters’ list, the committee acknowledges this to be the case. But the three-person panel also concluded “that the discrepancy between the number of ballots counted and the number of names crossed off the voters list is not an ‘irregularity,’ but rather an ‘error of record-keeping.’”And, where the Erskine-Smith campaign alleged that its observers had seen multiple instances of questionable documentation being used to prove identification and residency — key elements of vote eligibility — such as Amazon orders and travel visas, the panel decided that the on-site officials simply made the best of a tricky situation.“Faced with unconventional forms of documentation,” the panel wrote, the staff “considered the sufficiency of that documentation as well as other information from the individual, then made individualized eligibility determinations, amended the list of acceptable forms of documents, or both.”That sounds like a very legalese way of saying “figured things out on the fly.”The panel correctly points out that nomination races aren’t held to the same standards as elections. They aren’t even required, with the Liberal leader able to choose candidates by fiat. But a supporter of Erskine-Smith could be forgiven for being disillusioned by the whole process.Faced with all of his allegations, the tenor of the panel’s report is best summed up by the sentence that said the evidence at the hearing “presents a picture of a lively nomination meeting attended by a diverse array of voters.”Shrug emoji, jazz hands, nothing to see here.Erskine-Smith has not yet commented publicly after the dismissal of his appeal, nor has he said whether he still intends to run for the provincial leadership. (On the eve of the Scarborough nomination vote, he described himself as “leaving federal politics” on his social media accounts.)Sometimes political parties benefit from having an outsider leadership candidate who isn’t beholden to the party establishment.If nothing else, Erskine-Smith would, at this point, very much be that. Join the Conversation This website uses cookies to personalize your content (including ads), and allows us to analyze our traffic. Read more about cookies here. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.