As the South African Communist Party prepares for its 'Conference of the Left', the inclusion of right-wing populist formations raises critical questions about the future of socialism in South Africa.

The inclusion of right-wing populist formations in the South African Communist Party (SACP) ‘Conference of the Left’ to be held at the end of the month alongside formations such as the African National Congress (ANC) and the uMkhonto weSizwe Party (MKP), can only escalate rather than resolves the deep contradictions facing the South African left today. The SACP’s contradiction is no longer merely ideological; it is political, organisational, and material. This is reflected in the lived experiences of workers facing unemployment, austerity, collapsing public services, and intensified exploitation, while organisations claiming to represent socialism remain tied to forces responsible for administering the capitalist crisis.

At the centre of this contradiction lies a decisive question: how can a party claim to advance socialism while simultaneously participating in and defending a capitalist state? For three decades, the SACP has remained embedded within the Alliance led by the ANC, a governing formation that has implemented neoliberal economic policies which have deepened inequality, privatised and casualised labour, imposed fiscal austerity, and attacked the public sector. Yet the SACP continues to speak the language of socialism, radical economic transformation, and working-class emancipation. This creates a profound crisis of political credibility.