No matter the season, I’m always on the hunt for a foolproof way to catch a tan — sprays, mousses, bronzing SPFs, you name it. I’ve tried it all. Some work like magic, others... not so much. But this intensive tanning gel caught my attention — and not just because it comes with a cute wooden spatula to scoop out product without gunking up your nails (yes, really). It’s a 5-ounce jar of tanning gold.

Let’s talk formula. It’s powered by a blend of coconut oil and sesame oil, along with calendula extract, and skin-loving vitamins A and E. The star ingredient is beta-carotene — the same compound pigment that gives carrots their color. When paired with a little sun exposure, it helps develop a rich, natural-looking tan. The texture is a bit like Vaseline (but in the best way) — it left my skin silky smooth with an instant sun-kissed glow.

Pro tip: Wash your hands immediately after applying. Nothing gives away a faux glow faster than orange-tinted fingers that make you look like you’ve been elbow-deep in a bag of Cheetos.

I slathered the tanning gel on before lounging by the pool and even took a quick dip. By the end of my session, I had a subtle, even glow — without feeling greasy or looking streaky. Now, we know basking in the sun isn’t exactly skin-friendly, and please note that this product doesn’t contain any UV protection, so make sure to layer in your SPF if you’re headed outside to catch some rays.