This baking sheet has a “well thought out design” that consists of two pieces: a copper baking sheet to catch grease and crumbs and a three-quart copper perforated cage that ensures air circulates between every crevice. This results in an evenly cooked dish, crisping foods like an air fryer, and, similarly to those bulky devices, without using any cooking oils.
Clean-up is a cinch; many reviewers say they simply wipe it clean when done cooking, though the set is also dishwasher-safe. “Food barely sticks and cleans off with some liquid soap and only a paper towel,” says a reviewer. “I then place it on the top rack of the dishwasher for further cleaning and it comes out looking like new; no peeling coating and no staining.”
“I am really pleased with this product. Construction insures many years of usage. Well thought out design for air frying in an oven. After several uses, I continue to be impressed for the ease of cleaning, even cooking and down right attractive. Can’t make myself take it off the kitchen counter. GOOD job Gotham Steel.” — Jfrank
“I had purchased another version of this product that was made by Copper Chef. I used it in my Breville Smart Oven Air. It was smaller than the Gotham Steel Crisper XL and worked well at first. I then noticed the ‘coating’ beginning to peel off with each use. It also was difficult to clean and, contrary to the advertised commercials, food stuck to the surfaces and was hard to clean off. After having to wash it by hand, I then put it into the top rack of the dishwasher. After several months, I was too concerned about the health effects of the peeling coating to continue using it. That’s when I decided to try again, but with the Gotham Steel Crisper Tray XL. This tray fits about twice as much as the other one. For a point of reference, with this tray I can make up to 12 chicken wings at a time vs only 6 with the smaller Copper Chef Crisper Tray.
