Some folks are easy to shop for. They drop strong hints or create wishlists so people have at least a basic idea of where to start looking for their birthday and other gifting occasions. Other people, more specifically men, rarely make it that simple and finding out what they want is like pulling teeth.

With that in mind, we surveyed guys we know (ages ranging from 24 to 74) to find out what gifts are actually on their list. From budget-friendly to big ticket splurges, hopefully this list helps you find the perfect present for the fellas in your life who aren’t offering any guidance.